Quick Shrimp Cocktail Cups

Quick Shrimp Cocktail Cups are my answer to summer parties and last minute guests. These little lettuce boats burst with juicy shrimp and a tangy homemade sauce for a starter that feels crisp and elegant yet comes together in twenty minutes from pantry and fridge staples. Whenever I serve them, the whole tray disappears before I’ve even sat down.

I remember making these after a spontaneous backyard gathering the first hot weekend of spring and watching everyone go back for seconds. Now it is a recipe I always keep shrimp in the freezer for.

Ingredients

• Large cooked shrimp: offers a tender texture and naturally sweet taste go for wild caught for best flavor and look for firm moist flesh
• Fresh lemon: brightens both the shrimp and sauce pick ones with smooth skin and a bit of give when pressed
• Butter lettuce or romaine: forms the perfect crisp edible cup check leaves for no browning at the edges
• Ketchup: gives the cocktail sauce its signature tang opt for one with minimal added sugar
• Prepared horseradish: delivers heat and zing look for it in the refrigerated section for best brightness
• Fresh lemon juice: sharpens the sauce squeeze it right before mixing
• Worcestershire sauce: adds umami depth a little goes a long way and it can contain anchovies so check labels if needed
• Hot sauce (optional): for a punch of spice choose your favorite brand for customizing heat level
• Salt and freshly cracked black pepper: round out the flavors use flaky salt and grind pepper just before mixing
• Fresh chives or parsley for garnish: bring freshness pick vibrant green herbs with no wilting
• Lemon wedges: serve alongside so everyone can squeeze their own at the table

Instructions

Prepare the Shrimp

Pat the shrimp thoroughly dry with paper towels this prevents everything from turning watery then squeeze half a lemon evenly over them to infuse brightness and take away any fishy notes set aside so they develop flavor while you prep the rest

Make the Cocktail Sauce

In a small bowl whisk together the ketchup horseradish lemon juice Worcestershire sauce hot sauce salt and a generous dose of cracked pepper whisk until smooth and slightly airy dip a shrimp and adjust any seasoning right now for perfect balance

Assemble the Lettuce Cups

Lay out your lettuce leaves on a platter or individual plates gently press the center to create a small bowl shape these will hold the filling and look beautiful arranged like flower petals

Sauce in the Cup

Spoon a heaping tablespoon or two of your freshly mixed cocktail sauce into the base of each lettuce cup try to spread it out so the shrimp gets a bit with every bite

Fill with Shrimp

Divide the shrimp evenly among the lettuce cups arranging them attractively on top of the sauce pressing gently so they nestle into the leaves and the sauce cradles each piece

Add Freshness

Sprinkle the chopped chives or parsley right over the shrimp let some fall onto the greens for color and aroma this is where the dish starts looking party ready

Serve with Lemon

Arrange lemon wedges on the side for everyone to give an extra squeeze right before eating which wakes up every component with brightness

Save to Pinterest

I always look forward to the moment when I add the lemon at the table because the aroma takes me right back to family picnics by the lake. Shrimp was always a treat for us growing up so this recipe feels nostalgic and special even though it is so quick.

Storage Tips

Leftover shrimp cocktail cups are best enjoyed immediately because lettuce wilts quickly in the sauce. If you want to make ahead keep the shrimp cocktail mixture separate from the lettuce and assemble just before serving. Store the shrimp and sauce covered in the coldest part of your fridge for up to twenty four hours. If you have extra cocktail sauce it works beautifully as a dip for raw veggies or even roasted potatoes.

Ingredient Substitutions

If you cannot find butter lettuce try little gem or baby romaine leaves for crispness. For a lighter cocktail sauce stir in a spoonful of Greek yogurt in place of some ketchup which makes it creamy and tangy. Not a fan of horseradish Feel free to use wasabi or skip it and just increase the lemon and pepper for extra punch. You can also swap in pre cooked frozen shrimp if fresh is not available just thaw and dry well.

Serving Suggestions

Serve these shrimp cocktail cups on a big tray for self serve appetizers or plate two or three per person as a light lunch with a handful of sliced cucumber or avocado on the side. For parties line them up on a platter garnished with extra herbs and lemon wedges. They are also great alongside fresh fruit skewers for a brunch spread.

Cultural and Historical Context

Shrimp cocktail is a classic American appetizer dating back to the early twentieth century originally served in chilled coupe glasses. Lettuce cups give a modern twist offering crunch and finger food convenience. This upgrade is perfect for today’s lighter entertaining and makes the dish feel bright and fun. Growing up in a seafood loving family we always had shrimp on special occasions and these cups capture that feeling with less fuss.

Seasonal Adaptations

Swap in cherry tomatoes diced cucumber or thin sliced radish for extra crunch in the summer. Add a sprinkle of pomegranate seeds in winter for a festive look and tart flavor. In spring tuck in pea shoots or microgreens for added freshness.

Success Stories

At my last friends gathering these disappeared within minutes and even the kids wanted seconds. One guest loved them so much she asked for the recipe right away. I have also served them at work lunches to rave reviews because people appreciate something crunchy and light yet full of classic flavor.

Freezer Meal Conversion

While lettuce and sauce do not freeze well you can freeze cooked shrimp in a single layer then transfer to a bag and store for up to a month. Thaw in the fridge and pat dry before using to prevent excess moisture. You can whip up the sauce fresh and assemble just before serving.

Save to Pinterest

These shrimp cups vanish fast, so be sure to grab one while you can. They will brighten up any table and impress even last minute guests!

Common Recipe Questions

→ Can frozen shrimp be used?

Yes, thawed frozen cooked shrimp work well. Ensure they are fully drained and patted dry for best texture.

→ What alternatives can I use for lettuce cups?

Endive leaves, radicchio, or mini romaine hearts all provide a sturdy, crisp vessel for the shrimp and sauce.

→ How spicy is the cocktail sauce?

The spiciness can be adjusted by adding or omitting hot sauce. Taste and modify to your preference.

→ What herbs work best as garnish?

Fresh chives or parsley add a bright flavor. Dill or cilantro can also enhance the dish nicely.

→ Is this suitable for a dairy-free diet?

Yes, the ingredients are naturally dairy-free. Check sauce labels to ensure compliance for allergies.

→ Can these be made ahead?

Prepare shrimp and sauce ahead, but assemble cups just before serving for best texture and freshness.